Ep. 141 - How to Raise Kids Who Think for Themselves
Kids aren’t dumb—they’re developing. But in a world of endless stimulation, many children never slow down long enough to think past the next TikTok craze or YouTube short. In this episode of the All Pro Dad podcast, Ted Lowe is joined by BJ Foster and Bobby Lewis to talk about why thinking deeply matters and how dads can intentionally develop that skill through critical thinking activities for kids.
Why This Matters
Kids who learn to think critically become wiser decision-makers, better problem solvers, and more thoughtful adults.
Key Takeaways
– Critical thinking develops over time.
Kids naturally think about what’s directly in front of them. Development plays a major role, but dads can help move them from simply reacting to actually reasoning through situations.
– Today’s world makes deep thinking difficult.
Constant stimulation, shorter attention spans, fewer kids reading for fun, and the disappearance of boredom all work against developing thoughtful children.
– Dads can intentionally teach kids to think.
Critical thinking isn’t just an academic skill. It helps kids consider consequences, understand different perspectives, solve problems, and make wise decisions throughout life.
Practical Tips for Dads
1. Create a slow-thinking environment.
Reduce constant stimulation, allow boredom, limit screens, and introduce activities like chess, books, and uninterrupted conversations that naturally develop deeper thinking.
2. Ask better questions.
Instead of giving answers, ask open-ended questions like:
- “Why do you think that?”
- “What do you think happened?”
- “What would you do differently?”
Follow-up questions teach kids how to think, not just what to think.
- 3. Stretch your child’s time horizon.
Help kids connect today’s decisions with tomorrow’s outcomes. Talk about future goals, long-term consequences, and the kind of person they want to become.
Important Episode Timestamps
[00:00] Why Don’t Our Kids Think Critically and What Can Dads Do About It?
Ted introduces the episode’s central question and sets up a practical conversation about why critical thinking is so hard for kids, what gets in the way, and how to teach critical thinking to kids.
[00:30] Chicken on the Table and Other Signs Your Kids Aren’t Thinking
Bobby, BJ, and Ted share laugh-out-loud moments of their kids doing things that made them stop and go “what were you thinking?” — including Bobby’s son dropping a handful of chicken directly on the dinner table with no plate.
[03:17] Why Kids Aren’t Wired to Think Critically Yet
Bobby explains that critical thinking develops in stages, beginning around age six and not becoming fully complete until age 25.
[04:12] The Difference Between Parroting and Actually Thinking
BJ warns dads not to mistake kids repeating phrases they’ve heard on TV for genuine critical thinking skills for kids.
[08:41] What Critical Thinking Actually Means in Kid Terms
Ted breaks down critical thinking into language dads can actually use with their kids.
[09:36] Teaching Kids to See From Other Angles and Think Consequences Through
BJ shares how his dad teaching him chess trained his brain to calculate consequences before acting, a habit that stayed with him for life.
[12:55] What’s Getting in the Way of Kids Thinking Critically Today
The biggest obstacles to critical thinking in kids today are shrinking attention spans, constant screen stimulation, a dramatic drop in reading for fun, and a future that feels too far away to bother thinking about.
[16:35] Why Dads Need to Show Kids That the World Is Bigger Than Their Bubble
Ted makes the case that exposing kids to perspectives and realities outside their own world is one of the most powerful ways to develop critical thinking.
[19:44] Practical Ways to Build Critical Thinking Into Everyday Life
Ted and BJ walk through simple, low-pressure ways to practice critical thinking with kids.
[23:12] This Week’s Pro Move:
Ask your child one thoughtful question this week—and resist the urge to answer it for them. Give them time to think.
Sponsor:
The All Pro Dad Podcast is proudly brought to you by Family First, a nonprofit dedicated to equipping parents with resources to strengthen their families. Learn more at FamilyFirst.net.
All Pro Dad Resources
Connect with Us:
Connect with Ted Lowe
Connect with BJ
Connect with Bobby
- Subscribe to the All Pro Dad Podcast on Apple Podcasts
- Follow us on Facebook | X | Instagram
- Watch the Full Episode on YouTube
Don’t forget to leave us a review on your favorite podcast app!
Join nearly 200,000 other dads by subscribing to the All Pro Dad Play of the Day. Get daily fatherhood ideas, insight, and inspiration sent straight to your inbox.